How to Choose an Egg Donor Agency

Clinics often hand intended parents a long list of agencies with no way to tell them apart. Here's what an agency actually does, a vetting checklist drawn from real intended parents' experiences, and the red flags worth walking away from.

Reviewed by Conner, Co-Founder & Research Lead

See what it costs →

Verify donor profiles independently

Fabricated or AI-generated donor photos are a documented problem at some banks — reverse-search before you commit.

Ask when the donor's age was recorded

Application age and retrieval-date age can differ for repeat donors — get the specific cohort's date.

Agency vs. egg bank changes the timeline, not just the price

A fresh cycle through an agency and a frozen lot from a bank trade off cost, speed and egg quantity differently.

The basics

What an egg donor agency actually does

An agency recruits and screens donors, maintains their profiles, coordinates the medical and psychological evaluation, matches you with a candidate, and manages the logistics of a fresh retrieval cycle timed to your treatment. It is, as one recipient parent put it bluntly in an online forum, "100% a business" — agencies are connecting you with gametes for a fee, not running a charity, and it's worth evaluating them the way you'd evaluate any vendor handling something this consequential.

Vetting checklist

Questions to ask before you commit

  1. How do you recruit and screen donors? Ask specifically about medical, genetic and psychological screening, and what disqualifies a candidate.
  2. What happens if my donor is a poor responder, or the cycle produces no viable embryos? Get their policy in writing before you pay anything.
  3. What if a donor backs out mid-cycle? This happens more than agencies advertise — ask how they handle it.
  4. What deposits are required, and what's refundable? Get a full written schedule of costs, not a single headline number.
  5. When was this donor's age and history last verified? A repeat donor's profile may show her age at first application rather than the retrieval date for the specific cohort you'd be purchasing — ask for the cohort-specific date directly.
  6. Can you verify this donor's photos are genuine? Reverse-image-search a donor's profile photos yourself. Fabricated and AI-generated donor images have been reported at more than one bank.
  7. Do you offer open, ID-disclosure, or anonymous donation, and can I choose? Policies vary by agency and matter for your future child's ability to access information later.
  8. What's your track record? Ask about live births from previous cohorts, not just donor headcount.
  9. Can I talk to a past client? A reference from a recent intended parent is more useful than testimonials on the agency's own site.
  10. Is this agency on my clinic's approved list? A clinic's list isn't a guarantee, but it's a reasonable starting filter — and you're not limited to it if you'd rather research independently.

Watch for

Red flags

  • Donor profiles you can't verify. Reverse-search photos. AI-generated or stock donor images are a documented, real problem, not a hypothetical one.
  • Vague answers about what's included in the price. If an agency won't itemize costs in writing, treat that as a warning sign, not an oversight.
  • Pressure to decide quickly. A rushed match is one of the most commonly cited regrets among intended parents who've been through this.
  • No clear cancellation or poor-responder policy. Ask before you need the answer, not after.
  • Representatives recruiting you directly in forums or comment sections. If someone is pitching their own agency rather than answering your actual question, that's self-interest, not advice.

The alternative

Agency vs. egg bank

An agency matches you with a donor for a fresh retrieval cycle timed to your treatment — typically more eggs, a longer timeline, and a higher cost. An egg bank sells already-frozen eggs from past donors in a fixed lot, usually six to eight eggs — faster and more predictable in cost, but you're buying a defined quantity with no option to request a second round from the same donor if the first doesn't produce a viable embryo. Neither route is inherently more trustworthy than the other; the vetting questions above apply whichever you choose. See the full cost breakdown for exactly how fresh and frozen compare in dollars.

The tradeoff intended parents actually describe going through it: a fixed lot is a known quantity up front, but it's still a gamble on outcome. Banks typically attach some form of guarantee to a lot — commonly a minimum number of blastocysts per lot purchased — but the terms vary by bank and by donor, and a guarantee is not the same as a live birth. Some intended parents get a strong result from a single lot; others report needing to purchase from a second or even a third lot after the first didn't produce a viable embryo, which erodes the cost and speed advantage banks are chosen for in the first place. That risk cuts the other way with fresh: a single retrieval can produce many more eggs, but a donor can also respond poorly, and there's no fallback lot to fall back on.

Questions worth asking a bank specifically, beyond the agency vetting checklist above: exactly what the guarantee covers (blastocysts, not embryos transferred or a live birth), what recourse you have if a lot underperforms, whether the lot's egg count and the donor's retrieval date match what's on the profile, and how many total live births that specific donor's previous lots have produced — not just the bank's aggregate success rate.

FAQ

Common questions

How do I know if an egg donor agency is reputable? Ask how they recruit and screen donors, what disqualifies a candidate, and how they handle a poor responder or a donor who backs out mid-cycle. Search the agency's name and each donor photo individually — fabricated or AI-generated donor profiles are a documented problem at some banks. Ask your clinic which agencies are on their approved list, and look for a track record of live births from past cohorts.

What's the difference between an egg donor agency and an egg bank? An agency matches you with a donor for a fresh retrieval cycle timed to your treatment. An egg bank sells already-frozen eggs from past donors in fixed lots, typically 6-8 eggs, usually with some form of blastocyst guarantee attached. Fresh usually costs more but tends to produce more eggs; frozen is faster and more predictable in cost, but a guarantee isn't a live birth, and some intended parents end up purchasing a second lot if the first doesn't produce a viable embryo.

What are red flags when choosing an egg donor agency? Unverifiable donor profiles, vague pricing, pressure to decide quickly, no clear policy for a cancelled or poor-responder cycle, and reluctance to explain how a donor's age or retrieval date is calculated.

Should I use the agency my clinic recommends? It's a reasonable starting point, but their list isn't a guarantee — ask the same screening questions about any agency on it, and know you're not limited to that list if you'd rather research independently.

Can I verify a donor's age and history myself? Ask whether the listed age reflects when she applied or when your specific cohort was retrieved — those can differ for repeat donors. Ask about live births from her previous cohorts directly.

Next step

See what your donor-egg cycle would cost

Once you know what to look for in an agency, the natural next question is the total bill — donor compensation, agency fee, the IVF cycle, and what a quote typically leaves out.

Egg donor cost breakdown →

Related resources

Keep exploring

This page is educational and not medical, legal or financial advice. Vet any agency independently and review contracts with your own counsel before signing.